With two more weeks of seminary left, I find myself away from Princeton and in San Antonio for the PCUSA Multicultural Conference. I have to admit that the first day and a half, I wasn’t sure what I was going to take away from the conference itself. Along the way, I have learned some tools for use in the local church and some important things going on in other areas of the denomination. But what has been far more meaningful to me are the wonderful relationships I have made with a few awesome pastors and elders in the Presbytery of Charlotte. These are good people ya’ll. Yes, I said ya’ll.
There’s something freeing about being among people from your home neck of the world. Humor, concern, care – we learn how to communicate our feelings, longings, even our silliness in the context of unique cultures. We use particular mannerisms, idioms, and props to express ourselves, and when someone immediately responds appropriately to what we’ve tried to communicate, we feel affirmed, understood, and free to express ourselves again. When we express ourselves and don’t receive congruent feedback, we have to try harder, communicating becomes a task, anxiety creeps in, and we refrain from expressing ourselves as readily as we might in other situations.
I didn’t realize until I was with these people from Charlotte how hard I have had to work the past three years in seminary to communicate with other people, express myself, find understanding, and reflect all of these things for other people. Within 24 hours of being in San Antonio with the group from Charlotte, I began to feel understood – held even – by these people – and able to freely express myself in ways that it took me two – three years to do so with people in seminary or in church up north.
Neris, one of the women from Charlotte, also had an interesting awakening while here at the conference. Yesterday, worship began with a mariachi band. The band began to play, people started clapping, and Neris’ face lit up. She turned to Warren and said, “This is so wonderful! I had forgotten what it was like to be Latina in Charlotte”.
Neris told the group later that she thinks she just set aside a whole part of her culture in order to adapt to American culture in Charlotte. She hasn’t outrightly denied her culture, but neither has she found a place in which she can really express those aspects of her culture that give her life, make her face light up, make her feel comfortable, excited, and renewed.
Our experiences reaffirm for me what has to remain central to whatever we do in the way of multicultural ministries. Neris and I are sisters in Christ. We have shared just a piece of our lives with one another. We have expressed our desire to support one another in our lives and ministries in Charlotte. We enjoy learning from one another about those things that are unique to our cultures which might enrich the life of the other in another culture. And yet, we both need the cultures, including the religious expressions, which have shaped our lives and which continue to give us life, make us feel understood, and enable us to express ourselves authentically, both with others and with God.
People must be able to express themselves freely, with their own manners, idioms, and props, so that they can seek authentic spiritual experiences and serve others with joy and love. If the church can’t find a way to make room for that, for people of all different cultures, generations, sexualities, economic status, etc, the church might as well get out of the way.
Many people – in and out of the church – quickly dismiss the church as racist, irrelevant, ridiculous – whatever. But at the end of the day, and in honor of BGLASS week at PTS, “It’s about people”. (I can just hear someone criticizing me from one angle, “Of course it’s about people. It’s always been about people out for themselves and what they can gain at the expense of another person. Hell with it.” I can hear others saying, “No, no, no. It’s not about us, it’s about God”. I get it).
Bottom line is, the people with whom I have been joined in love to hold up and lean on through all the trials and celebrations of life, they are church (whether they’ve ever set foot in a church). These people are valuable gifts of love for me, and I know they are powerful presences of hope for other people. And our relationships ought not depend on the rise and fall of particular ecclesial institutions. In fact, these relationships should be what critique, reform, and recreate church institutions in service to our witness to the love of God, which animates us in and through our particular cultures.
And yet … people continue to seek to control one another and everything else under the sun. PCUSA polity continues to be at times a blessing, but on many occasions a curse. How well does the proposed new PCUSA polity address issues of decentralizing power? In the words of Dr. Rivera Pagan, “OK. Discuss”.